Why you shouldn't water cool your PC

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 30 April 2019
  • Thanks, World of Tanks for sponsoring today's video! Use invite code TANKTASTIC at tanks.ly/2U1zt9C and get a T-127 Tank, 500 Gold, and 7 Days Premium Access.

    AIO water coolers seem to be all the rage, but we're here to tell you that big air coolers are where it's at. Probably.

    Buy a NH-U12A
    On Amazon: geni.us/9xIfzT
    On Newegg: geni.us/oF1ydNC

    Discuss on the forum: linustechtips.com/main/topic/1059701-why-you-shouldnt-water-cool-your-pc/

    Our Affiliates, Referral Programs, and Sponsors: linustechtips.com/main/topic/75969-linus-tech-tips-affiliates-referral-programs-and-sponsors
    Get Private Internet Access today at geni.us/7lLuafK
    Displate metal posters: lmg.gg/displateltt

    Linus Tech Tips merchandise at LTTStore.com/
    Linus Tech Tips posters at crowdmade.com/linustechtips
    Our Test Benches on Amazon: amazon.com/shop/linustechtips
    Our production gear: geni.us/cvOS

    Twitter - twitter.com/linustech
    Facebook - facebook.com/LinusTech
    Instagram - instagram.com/linustech
    Twitch - twitch.tv/linustech

    Intro Screen Music Credit:
    Title: Laszlo - Supernova
    Video Link: changsongsteel.ru/user/watch?v=PKfxmFU3lWY
    iTunes Download Link: itunes.apple.com/us/album/supernova/id936805712
    Artist Link: soundcloud.com/laszlomusic

    Outro Screen Music Credit: Approaching Nirvana - Sugar High changsongsteel.ru/user/approachingnirvana
  • Science and Technology Science and Technology

Comments • 9 490

  • SympleSynz
    SympleSynz  4 hours back

    I ended up switching to the Thermaltake Engine 27 after my AIO died on me. Best move I ever made. Unbelievably quiet and efficient.

    • Germ Kun
      Germ Kun  6 hours back

      I always make sure my temp is around 28-36 idle and 40-55 while gaming... not exceeding... How do you do it? buy a good cpu cooler and highquality thermal paste

      • m. deicke
        m. deicke  8 hours back

        liked the Noctua cooler but gave up trying to build a system that could fit it.

        • d flowers
          d flowers  15 hours back

          I hate adding my 2 cents to this but part of the problem with water cooling has to do with the block itself. How much heat can be transferred from the CPU to the block and how much heat can be transferred from the block to the water is directly proportional to the surface area of the block in contact with the CPU and the surface area of the block in contact with the water. Since the surface area of the water block in contact with the CPU is pretty much fixed the same as it would be in an air cooling rig what has to be played with is the surface area that the water comes into contact with. In a single layer block that is limited. It is also not as simple as simply stacking water blocks, since you have to be able to transfer heat through one water block into the other water block and you don't want the water to be doing the heat transfer from one block to another. Heat pipes in air cooled setups increase the effective surface area of the transfer and the same needs to be done in water cooling. The radiator is less of an issue than the water block as the size of the radiator can be increased relatively easily. The gist is that you either need two water blocks with the one in contact with the CPU having more metal to transfer to the second water block or a thicker water block that is constructed so as to allow heat to transfer through the metal farther, possibly something like a V grooved water channel where the point of the V is pointing to the CPU if that makes sense. This would allow the heat to be drawn further up the water block giving more surface area for the water to pull the heat away from the water block. I guess another answer would be to use heat pipes between to connect water blocks. I really don't understand why the water block manufacturers are fixated on such small water blocks. Just making the water block twice as thick with a narrower channel would allow the same water flow but more heat transfer, maybe not twice as much heat transfer but still more.

          • Michael Haddon
            Michael Haddon  17 hours back

            You never clarified whether you were using the same exact CPU and thermal paste for the test. Theres a significant gap in credibility of the test if you arent. when I say same exact, I mean taking the cooler off the cpu and putting the next cooler on after each test.

            • Taut Tech / Minus Managed Music

              So, custom water cooling.

              • Evan R
                Evan R  20 hours back

                What was that PC case he had? Paused the video a few times but can't make out the name.

                • Teguh Wijaya
                  Teguh Wijaya  21 hours back

                  but what if it leaaaakkkkss, the scary catastrophic for me is leak, all dead at once

                  • D-rex
                    D-rex  1 days back

                    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hr0qLLv3dKc contradiction

                    • Geoffrey Zoref
                      Geoffrey Zoref  2 days back

                      I don't think my jio does all that much better than the 3600 default heatsink

                      • Jessie Janson
                        Jessie Janson  2 days back

                        The big difference is the noctua fans, they offer much better performance with lower sound levels compared to anything else around. So really the test is "really good water cooling with average fans" VS. "Really good fans with average heatsink". If you were to opt to use the noctua fans with the water cooling loop, you are practically guaranteed to get results that are much better. Im disappointed that they didnt test this.

                        • vasllz
                          vasllz  2 days back

                          "move your pc safer" as an argue for Watercooling ???? come on, if you aware of that you can just remove your aircooler, it s like 3 min job

                          • evilal20
                            evilal20  2 days back

                            Think of it like an engine...
                            Air cooled engines don't disperse the heat as evenly, majority of the heat building up along the firewall because the poor air flow, resulting in some cylinders running hotter than others.
                            Now for water cooled engines, they're more expensive/pain in the ass to repair, but it evenly disperse the heat through the engine, evenly cooling each cylinder, in turn consistent operating temperatures, in result giving better fuel economy.

                            • Ahorn Staub
                              Ahorn Staub  2 days back

                              I always add some self build stabilisators to air coolers, and if i woud go warter cooling woud always go with custom cooling and a readiator taken form an engine cooler form a load power were.

                              • blek 353
                                blek 353  2 days back

                                If you will play world of tanks, play russian tanks. They are the best because wargaming is Belarussian company.

                                2nd tip:
                                Don't play german heavy tanks when you yust started because they are underpovered (mid tier ones).

                                • Stephen Miller
                                  Stephen Miller  2 days back

                                  Love the channel Linus YOU ARE "THE MAN!". I'd advise, as a fan, stop the poor people disses. Poor people like computers too and they can hear the diss. It's like the time you upgraded your gaming beast with parts (top of the line parts that you got; for all apparent purposes FREE). It should be noted that you work your azz off providing content and reviewing products and just doing cool stuff with things your viewers may not have access to so there is plenty 'o work involved in what it is you do that affords you these luxuries. The point is, the less fortunate find it hard to see anything from someone else's perspective because after the video is over they go back to their reality. Just making an observation because you seem to care, but the passive disses are still there saying LOUDLY, that you actually don't.

                                  • Kotau
                                    Kotau  3 days back

                                    Yeah I don't think that whoever designed water-cooling as a "95% soundless cooling option" accounted for noise cancelling headphones. Seems like a fair oversight. Albeit I think that if it gets cheaper enough, which I doubt because air cooling is inherently just more simple, then it'll get more mainstream around the world.
                                    But I think it'll stay as it is (an alternative form of cooling for people who like its looks) until

                                    • Passrbra
                                      Passrbra  3 days back

                                      What if there isn't as much room inside the tower and then compare the pure cooling performance to a front mounted radiator?

                                      • St0RM33
                                        St0RM33  3 days back

                                        Isn't the NH-D15 even better?

                                        • Droid Motorola 388
                                          Droid Motorola 388  3 days back

                                          I got an answer a single leak of water can burn your whole PC even your whole house

                                          • eivindrew
                                            eivindrew  3 days back

                                            Went from a full blown WC loop in my old Obsidian 800D with 360+240 to a NZXT H500 with the NH-D14
                                            The change was needed as the loop got old and clogged, of course it was one hell of a ride, tinkering with it, great performance. But down the line, getting close to moving, I wanted to downgrade.
                                            In the end, it has become a slight upgrade. To me, it was a change very much needed. I never moved that full tower beast, and I were not comfortable with the idea of moving it with the loop in mind.

                                            Custom water loop does indeed need maintenance, at least once a year, I started to neglect that, as the loop had no quick connects for drain or even the money and energy anymore.
                                            One day I might get back to it. But for now, Noctua has proven another realm of cooling for me. It's much cooler, and much more silent.

                                            I even managed to fit a E-ATX board in the H500, and with a millimeter to spare, the NH-D14.

                                            Tho I must say, I did equip the top exhaust fan at the top, to the outside, with a fan guard and just disconnected the header and lined them through the fan grill.
                                            Kinda like I did with the 800D for a push/pull config. Looks a little bit shabby, but does the job quite well.

                                            • Zykelator
                                              Zykelator  3 days back

                                              Not everyone wants silent pc though.

                                              • Sp4m Solo
                                                Sp4m Solo  3 days back

                                                Use a extra fan on the radiator. Works much better

                                                • Blue Tex
                                                  Blue Tex  3 days back

                                                  Why is it when I play fortnite on my gaming laptop it's only using 20-40 cpu usage, and I fell a part of the laptop it's hotter then lava😒 wtf

                                                  • St0RM33
                                                    St0RM33  3 days back

                                                    the dust and the lint that gathers up with time and blocks all airflow. I have such a laptop and i clean and re-paste every 6 months. Although i use it 24/7

                                                  • Blue Tex
                                                    Blue Tex  3 days back

                                                    @St0RM33 what junk?

                                                  • St0RM33
                                                    St0RM33  3 days back

                                                    because the heatsink is too small..that's why the noctua cooler is so big. You also need enough heatpipes. You can modify your laptop heatsink if you are into it, but for start just use liquid metal thermal paste and you will see huge difference. Also time to clean the junk.

                                                • Imaproshaman
                                                  Imaproshaman  3 days back

                                                  Oh, neat!

                                                  • Manix Burn
                                                    Manix Burn  4 days back

                                                    Sadly the evaluation is not complete watercooling directly extract heat from the pc, this can make make graphic card run quieter and cooler...

                                                    • paduag1782
                                                      paduag1782  4 days back

                                                      What if you just get a ZERO BREEZE A/C unit to cool the internals?

                                                      • Winfield Lauer
                                                        Winfield Lauer  4 days back

                                                        I've ran 3 different cooling systems. A custom build, Thermaltake, and a aio. And all 3 failed in a 1-2 year time. I've switched to 212 and have not looked back. And now you just said what I experienced. Dead pump. Not changing from air again

                                                      • SteroidalTacoSauce
                                                        SteroidalTacoSauce  4 days back

                                                        Back when I was a wee lad, I had a phenom II 970 with a stock cooler and insufficient thermal paste which would crash under load in normal house temps, so for 2 weeks over the winter I had one room of the house with completely open windows. A nice tropical 15°F and 0°F nights, let me limp it along until my new system had arrived. What a time it was to be alive. 50ft of vga and wireless mouse and keyboard. Was quite a ghetto set up. Linus approved.

                                                        • Farzad Izaddoustdar
                                                          Farzad Izaddoustdar  4 days back

                                                          What about the EK gaming range? Aluminum based custom water cooling for very reasonable prices!

                                                          • part1cle
                                                            part1cle  4 days back

                                                            I want to buy a be quiet! dark rock pro 4 and a carbonaut thermal pad so I'm done with cooling forever.

                                                            • PJ Noonan
                                                              PJ Noonan  4 days back

                                                              You're right Linus. Use Life of Boris patent, Vodka cooling system!

                                                              • 10 Billion Subs - 1 Sh*t video

                                                                my 8700k doesn't even exceed 70 while playing gta. plus my h80i has lasted through 3 systems so far.

                                                                • Caz Showalter
                                                                  Caz Showalter  5 days back

                                                                  GPU water cooled all day. My aorus 1080 ti xtreme has a ek water block on it now and went from 178f air cooled to 110f under full load auto over clocked to 2168. Now my 7700k 4.6 on the other hand I probably wont liquid cool again and go with a giant air cooler cause I dont see a difference full load is about 135f-140f.

                                                                  • Timon Gulyás
                                                                    Timon Gulyás  5 days back

                                                                    Well, what happens when your GPU has a load too. Wouldn't the heat from the GPU worsen the performance of aircooler blocks, and water coolers with top positioned radiators, but not affect front radiator watercoolers. So what's whit that? Would the aircooler still outpreform watercoolers then?

                                                                    • TedRampart Gaming
                                                                      TedRampart Gaming  5 days back

                                                                      I cool my cpu with only the ice cold stare of my 3rd grade teacher when I talked back.. nothing colder than that shit!

                                                                      • BerryVR
                                                                        BerryVR  5 days back

                                                                        I have a Thermaltake 360 Water Cooler and honestly I didn't see much lower temps than the air cooler I used (can't remember what make, cost around the same) but what I've done now is replace the 3 fans + brought 3 extra fans (for a push pull) these are 6 Noctua 120mm 3000rpm fans (+KingPin thermal paste). I am able to put 1.575v through a ryzen7 2700x and get 75*c. yes thats a stupid amount of voltage but it proves the point in cooling. try doing that with any air cooler. granted it sounds like I have a jet in my room, but with noise cancelation on headphones + mic for recording/streaming, legit noise is not noticable.

                                                                        this is just my experiance with cooling and I love to mess around with overclocking. I know the price is crazy but you would only worry about cooling if your overclocking in the first place so xD

                                                                        • Mac Madgunner
                                                                          Mac Madgunner  5 days back

                                                                          This is a good video, I like also that this video is sponsord by World of Tanks. I made a video about World of Tanks special event, Homefront i hope you check it out. World of Tanks 💥 Homefront ↪ Look back - Favorite tanks - Highlights ↩ 🎭 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdyDrXcKUC4

                                                                          • foamysking
                                                                            foamysking  5 days back

                                                                            Out of curiously did you use the default settings on the cosair water coolers? I have found when using them they crank keep the pump speed really low and that results in a much higher core temp. Where as if you crank up the pump speed the cooling performance is much improved about 10°f without any added sound and without ramping up the fan speed

                                                                            • JeremieBabin
                                                                              JeremieBabin  5 days back

                                                                              Hey Linus? I've been watching your show for a few years already. Loving alot of your videos and how you represent each product. But the truth is, I couldn't see a shred of appreciation for the other "lower" products. You're not even presenting the different products, you're simply trying to state that "this one" is the best! Isn't the point of you starting a youtube channel was to actually inform and help those who wanted to learn?

                                                                              Listen man, I really love what you do! But please man, don't be disrespectful to the other companies who actually poured their hearts and soul into making their machines. The engineers still tried their hardest. :)

                                                                              From a fellow Canadian!

                                                                              • Steve Cedrone
                                                                                Steve Cedrone  5 days back

                                                                                Just built an AMD Ryzen Thread Ripper Gen-2 24 Core and fully loaded the processor with it being cooled by a 360mm Enermax cooler and with the fans at around 2700rpm on the cooler the CPU sat at 27c (81F) even when it sat there for 24 hours like this.

                                                                                • BryanBrockAndrews
                                                                                  BryanBrockAndrews  5 days back

                                                                                  I feel like one advantage of liquid cooling that isn't mentioned is that it can pump your CPU heat right out the top or back without blowing hot air throughout the interior of your case. If your case isn't properly ventilated, an air cooler could spin as fast as it likes and just keep recirculating its own hot air. A liquid cooler blows the hot air outside the case immediately, which I think is an advantage worth mentioning.

                                                                                  • BeginnerLockPickingDiaries

                                                                                    How is it I hadn’t subscribed to *you guys* until just this year? Answer me this Linus!

                                                                                    • JustAllinOneResource
                                                                                      JustAllinOneResource  6 days back

                                                                                      Thank You for the Video. Liked, and Shared.

                                                                                      • Mikael Bolzan Machievizc

                                                                                        so world of tanks missed the oportunity of using the code LinusTankTips?

                                                                                        • N/A N/A
                                                                                          N/A N/A  7 days back

                                                                                          So why buy a Ferrari if you never drive above 70mph?

                                                                                        • Panic_ Cronical
                                                                                          Panic_ Cronical  7 days back

                                                                                          Well if you want to move your pc to some where cant you just take off your cooler

                                                                                          • Draegor X
                                                                                            Draegor X  7 days back

                                                                                            Linus, you failed to mention higher ambient temp. environments, like non-air conditioned rooms in summer.

                                                                                            • BoHjalmarGames
                                                                                              BoHjalmarGames  6 days back

                                                                                              Draegor X The water is cooked by air, so there won't be a difference as soon as the water gets heated up.